Skip to main content
Massachusetts State Seal
Commonwealth Museum   Secretary of the Commonwealth William Francis Galvin

Castle Island: The Famous and the Infamous


On July 31, 1799 President John Adams visited the island and designated the site “Fort Independent.” Possibly the President misspoke. It has been known as “Fort Independence” ever since.


“My thirst for amusement was insatiable.”

-  Stephen Burroughs

A portrait of Edgar Allen Poe

Edgar Allan Poe.  

a photo of casks

Casks of Amontillado
(a variety of sherry wine)

- JlJimenez photo

A photo of Enlistment Papers

Enlistment papers

Edgar Allan Perry?
Edgar Allan Poe had a troubled childhood. He enlisted in the army as “Edgar Allan Perry” and served at Fort Independence. Supposedly his story, the Cask of Amontillado, is based on an incident at the fort. A popular officer was killed in a duel and his assailant was trapped for eternity behind a bricked up wall (the same fate as an Italian nobleman in the story.) In reality the surviving duelist continued his military career for nearly thirty years. Perhaps Poe’s imagination was fired by the fort’s austere setting.

A portrait of John Adams

John Adams

A portrait of John Hancock

John Hancock

State Prison: The Notorious Stephen Burroughs
For a time Castle Island served as the state prison. One inmate, Stephen Burroughs, was the son of a Presbyterian minister, although his insatiable “thirst for amusement” led him astray. From childhood pranks he advanced to a life of crime including passing counterfeit coins. Burroughs offered high minded excuses including economic theories on the importance of expanding the money supply. He escaped from Castle Island with seven fellow inmates but distinguished himself by saving the life of a guard they had kidnapped. When recaptured he was spared flogging.

Nailing It
Burroughs was assigned to making nails and managed to produce only five a day. (He claimed that a larger number would lower the quality.) When promised a gill of rum if he and other inmates could produce 500 in a day, he made the quota. When the ration of rum did not appear the following day, Burroughs resumed his regular pace

A photo of an old book with an illustration and a title that reads "Memoirs, the notorious Stephen Burroughs".
Burroughs’ best-selling memoirs make entertaining reading even today. No doubt some incidents are more amusing two hundred years later.
- Internet Archive